Contribution to Istanbul INURA Study Visit by R.Wolff


santralistanbul, inura opening meeting.


Contribution to Istanbul INURA Study Visit


Istanbul, Comment by Richard Wolff (co-director of inura)

Summing up the Study Tour and Final Comment
Presented at Final Panel at Bilgi University, March 17, 2008


Preliminary Remark

I would like to present my impressions and conclusions in the form of three statements from three perspectives, each one inspired by and dedicated to three of urban development’s main theorists.

1 The Global City Project (Saskia Sassen)
2 Social Justice and the City (David Harvey)
3 Right to the City (Henri Lefebvre)



1 The Global City Project (Saskia Sassen)

Istanbul seems to be aspiring global city status. One should not forget that in Roman and Byzantyne times it had already had this status for a very long time. Constantinople was one of the world’s first and largest global cities.

In the current age of globalization, Istanbul has (re-)entered the competition for global city status. Many of the city’s visible developments, in architecture, urban design, urban regeneration, traffic infrastructure, preservation of monuments etc. reflect these global ambitions.

One handy way of putting this development into perspective is to subject Istanbul to a ‚quick and dirty’ SWOT-analysis. So what are the Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats (SWOTs)?

Strengths

- location (at a global transport crossroads)
- setting (natural beauty, hills, waterways)
- diversity (of peoples, cultures, ...)
- global openness (historic experience of tolerance)
- workforce (number and qualification)
- ...
Weaknesses

- international tensions (along Turkey’s borders and with EU)
- Turkey’s tendency for (self-) isolation
- unresolved conflicts inside Turkey
- ...
Opportunities

- commercial hub for the larger region
- potential for becoming one of the world’s most dynamic cities
- ...


Threats

- growing segregation
- social unrest (both not despite but because of investment)
- economic stagnation or decline because of unresolved political problems
- ...


International competition is prolonged / transmitted into competition between Istanbul’s districts. Beyoglu, Fatih, Eminönü etc. are rivals for prestige, image, status, and income. They compete for investment and good tax payers, both businesses and private. They all thrive for international standard and international style, and are thus anxious to ‚clean up’ their territories under the label of ‚physical and social renewal’. Whereas physical renewal can in many instances easily be understood as something unavoidable, the notion of social renewal must be questioned. The examples of Süleymanie, Sulukule, Tarlabasi neighbourhoods challenge us to ask ‚Who wins, who loses?’

2 Social Justic and the City

Is the current policy of regeneration in various neighbourhoods of Istanbul more oriented towards consensus or confrontation? Having looked at the examples mentioned above, we got the impression of a neo-liberal approach of development with increasing economic and social differences as a consequence of physical renewal. The erosion of the middle class and the total ignoring of the positive experiences with the Gecekondu style development (spontaneous, self-help, later legalized urbanization) are part of this plan.

During our tours and talks we were astonished to repeatedly hear rhetorics of war and disease when people talked about those neighbourhoods about to be gentrified. ‚Crime’, ‚drugs’, ‚prostitution’, ‚cancer growth’ were the reasons given to explain the urgency of tearing down and rebuilding entire neighbourhoods. As if to underline the seriousness of the situation the entrance to Tarlabasi is dominated by a police station with a police tank parked in front of it. All of this recalls Neil Smith’s notion of ‚Revanchist City’ where the poor are blamed for their poverty.

What is desperately lacking in this type of urban renewal are social / ethical values and a truly democratic process. Whereas it may be true that in urban development ‚you cannot always satisfy 100% of the people’ (a sentence we heard three times in two days), one should be suspicious when it is always the same 10, 20, or 30% who have to pay the price. What happens to those that again and again are being pushed around the city, those that are evicted from their homes and/or insufficiently compensated? How does the city deal with the weakest, those most vulnerable?

The democratic process should be strengthened. Participation, mediation, compensation are just a few of the demands to be put forward. In the observed regeneration processes everyone affected has to know much more of what is actually going on: information, transparency, honesty, a level playground are some of the key issues. Questions must be allowed and answered. All agents must be open to criticisms and alternative proposals. There has to be an open debate over development goals. The financial implications, e.g. a cost-benefit analysis, should be clear to everyone.


3 The Right to the City

What can we contribute to this development as an organization?
First of all, we can serve as watchdog. We can keep our open eyes on the processes that are taking place. We can report what is going on. However, we should be careful with premature judgments. We should be reluctant to present ourselves as ‚referees of last resort’. Secondly, we can provide analysis, ask critical questions, present examples of best practices and suggest alternative plans. And, thirdly, we can learn. Learn for us, learn for the network and then disseminate the knowledge gained on site.

What can we contribute from our local backgrounds?
We can offer experiences from local processes and struggles, what we learned under similar or differing conditions of e.g. global competition, CBD-expansion, gentrification, housing crises in our cities. And how we dealt with these forces and threats. We can tell about and explain forms of action and resistance we applied locally, their failures and their successes, from demonstrations to squats, from publicity work to coalition-building. Many of us have stories to tell about unwanted developments that have been blocked, and successful projects that could be realised thanks to a combination of factors and framework conditions.

We can offer best practices and point to new solutions, we can assist, counsel, advise, help lobbying, and describe alternative organizational approaches to current problems.

We can often re-assure others involved in local struggles that their experience is part of an over-arching struggle for resources, opportunities, chances. That they are not alone. That it is necessary to question and to criticize.

The struggle for the right to the city is not finished. It is something that has to
be demanded again and again. Only by this can we achieve a better and juster city.

There is no change without critique resistance and struggle.

Richard Wolff, end of March 2008

35 yorum:

癢癢 dedi ki...

感謝予我如此動感的blog!.........................

幸運之神 dedi ki...

生命如夏花洵爛;死如秋葉之靜美。 ..................................................

非常冷 dedi ki...

Circumstances are the rulers of the weak, instrument of the wise..........................

張怡伶 dedi ki...

It's great!!.............................................

于雅慧毓 dedi ki...

待人要誠心,做事要用心,勝負平常心。......................................................

嘉容嘉容 dedi ki...

.有價值的東西,都要付出代價。- ..................................................

o0625TaylorJ_Duraz dedi ki...

心中有愛,才會人見人愛。........................................

燕香criste0609opherc_hippl dedi ki...

thx u very much, i learn a lot

韋于倫成 dedi ki...

Fancy may kill or cure. ....................................................

517SeritaG_Jamar0 dedi ki...

卡通成人影片 免費視訊金瓶梅 中年聊天室 aio交友愛情館影片免費85 歐美交友 自拍女優 性感成人內衣表演秀 女同影片 援交偷拍實錄 激情免費視訊聊天室 女生愛愛影片 情趣按摩貼圖 18性愛 夢幻少女寫真館 線上成人影城 免費a片貼 杜雷斯 色情影片 一夜情 383成人網 完美女人視訊 玩美女人視訊 線上美女 辣妹裸體 人妻的秘密 人妻熟女館 情色視訊 空姐 a圖a片交流區 美女寫真貼圖區 85cc線上 微風視訊成人 嘟嘟聊天室 sp7777.com 絲襪貼圖 熟女援交留言板 成人情色網 Live173 免費ava片線上看 洪爺影城色情網線上看 大奶美女做愛影片 做愛sex 免費下載av片 成人巨乳圖片 成人 後宮電影a下載 限制級成人網 channel0204 高中性愛影片 模特兒走光露點寫真

皓珊 dedi ki...

成人貼站 中部視訊聊天 免費色情聊天室 av免費片 交友 最新女優排行 性感美女 777美女影片 學生妹偷拍 6k 聊天室 愛愛色情網 情趣影片 18禁免費看 台灣美少女自拍俱樂部 美腿影城 a片歐美 情色試看 色情榜 情色貼圖區 //bbs.x383.com/sexcity/ 完美女人影音聊天網 一夜情 情色美女圖 辣妹 人妻熟女系列 歐美超熟女 情人視訊 2009空姐招考 a片a圖分享區 美女自拍寫真 85cc免費影城85cc卡通 微風線上成人觀看 打嘟嘟成人網 777 貼圖貼片 援交桃園 嘟都情人色網 鋼管 無碼av貼圖 洪爺影視 大奶av女優免費看 sex520免費影片亞洲區 免費線上成人影片下載 巨乳 性愛持久 後宮網站 無碼 0204影城 免費線上性愛直播 走光秀

韋于倫成 dedi ki...

脾氣與嘴巴不好,就算心地再好,也不算好人~~~ ....................................................

彥君彥君 dedi ki...

your english is incredible............................................................

曾文詠 dedi ki...

you have a very successful business............................................................

蕭瑋英 dedi ki...

請繼續發表好文!加油加油加油! .................................................................

淑芬楊 dedi ki...

你的BLOG真有心~看都不膩.................................................................

佳燕 dedi ki...

一棵樹除非在春天開了花,否則難望在秋天結果。.................................................................

江婷 dedi ki...

生活總是起起伏伏,心情要保持快樂才好哦!!.................................................................                           

JonasTabr有香 dedi ki...

人有兩眼一舌,是為了觀察倍於說話的緣故。............................................................

王名仁 dedi ki...

當一個人內心能容納兩樣相互衝突的東西,這個人便開始變得有價值了。............................................................

欣怡 dedi ki...

great msg for me, thanks a lot dude˙﹏˙..................................................................

芳容222許林堅林芳容儀 dedi ki...

好看耶~一定每天有空給你支持..................................................................

淑蔡承均dgd周真淑ii淑 dedi ki...

光這幾句話就價值連城了,讀著讀著小弟的眼眶就濕了...............................................................

陳佑發 dedi ki...

Seeing is believing.百聞不如一見............................................................

吳勇佩吳勇佩 dedi ki...

你的部落內容真棒,一定要持續下去! ............................................................

芳綠 dedi ki...

喜歡自己的另一層意義是「接納自己」。..................................................

盈廖生家秀蔡 dedi ki...

Many a little makes a mickle..................................................................

許惠吟許惠吟 dedi ki...

Man proposes, God disposes..................................................................

吳許芝蓮佩儒 dedi ki...

量力而為,別勉強了,Cut your coat according to your cloth.............................................................

文岳仲君 dedi ki...

從來名利地,皆起是非心。.....................................................

玄王季玄王季玄王季 dedi ki...

與朋友在一起,分擔的痛苦是減半的痛苦,分享的快樂是加倍的快樂。......................................................................

偉曹琬 dedi ki...

大肚能容,了卻人間多少事,滿腔歡喜,笑開天下古今愁。..................................................

冠陳儒 dedi ki...

來塊巧克力吧~~心情會好哦~~...............................................................

惠奇 dedi ki...

累了嗎?來杯咖啡休息一下吧!...............................................................

陳智雅威宜 dedi ki...

安安唷~~幸運的日子送給妳(你)滿滿的幸福,也祝福你天天都開心唷............................................................